The Listening Tube Welcomes Lizzy Wright
Author and former spy Lizzy Wright shares with Bob some of the trials and tribulations of being a spy during the era of Osama bin Laden and how her book, Saffron Spy, is a reflection of it.
Info On The GoInfo On The Go is a family-friendly podcast for curious minds of all ages,...
Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify
Want to be a guest on The Listening Tube? Send Bob Woodley a message on PodMatch, here: https://www.podmatch.com/hostdetailpreview/thelisteningtube
09:50 - (Cont.)
SPEAKER_00
Hey, the listening tube welcomes a guest.
SPEAKER_01My guest today is author and former spy of the right. Well, she is no dream but she never says to be watched. She does provide some insight to the life of a spy. She also claims that life is behind her now, but can we ever really trust a spy? I think this time we can. Lizzie Wright spend some time with me in the listening tube from her home in Southern California.
SPEAKER_00An interview from the listening tube.
SPEAKER_01Knowing that you're a former spy, I can't help but wonder did you run a background check on me before you agreed to speak with me today?
SPEAKER_02I, you know, I'm a researcher by nature. Um, however, what you have at your disposal inside the intelligence community versus now me as just a private citizen, uh, totally different ballgame. And to be totally transparent, I would never run any type of scan on a U.S. citizen. That's uh that is a bridge too far in the world of intelligence, um, and that is an important barrier. Um, but I do, I think it's uh, you know, uh a legacy of my time there. I I do my homework and you know, I take it seriously um because I think, you know, the more it's true in business and it's true in intelligence, the more you understand, you know, who you're who you're interacting with, uh, the better the the outcome.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm I'm always craving constructive criticism. So I I guess I just I was hoping there was something out there that you may have discovered that I didn't know about.
SPEAKER_02Oh. Well, uh you would have to tell me what are the surprises.
SPEAKER_01Well, uh, uh I did do a background check on you.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01And it turns out that you and I may have been among the same group of people at the same time on a number of occasions, unless, of course, only your husband was there.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. I have a feeling that this has something to do with sports journalism, but I might be wrong.
SPEAKER_01It does. And the place I'm speaking of is the Los Angeles Coliseum.
SPEAKER_02Ah, he spent many a day there.
SPEAKER_01I used to go see the Raiders play there when they were when they were in LA. And uh and so our our paths may have crossed there on a number of occasions.
SPEAKER_02Sure. He spent seven years with the Raiders in Los Angeles, so there's a very good chance. Although that parking lot could be quite, you know, a a crazy scene. And he'd always you know tell me the stories of when he'd leave and the fans, and it's you know, the pageantry that uh that came with the Raiders fan fandom.
SPEAKER_01Some of the craziest tailgate parties I have ever seen in my life or at the LA Coliseum. For those
SPEAKER_02right. And you what's interesting is even now with the Raiders being in in Las Vegas and you know, having had many rough years, um, the fans they are diehards and they are lifers. And there's something special about that when you don't give up on your team.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Now, I'd love to talk to you about that, but let's leave your husband out of this for now.
SPEAKER_02All right.
SPEAKER_01How much of your novel, Saffron Spy, is a reflection of your real life experiences?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I because this has to be run through the intelligence community, and they gave the blessing after reading the manuscript. Much of my sources and methods or specific details of the things I did, none of that is in this book, nor is it focused on bin Laden. Um, I completely needed to change my focus of the book. So I use a fictitious Iranian network of uh a terrorism network, which at the time Iran wasn't really, I mean, sure, they're always in the news, but wasn't in the news they are, you know, like they are in the last or have been in the last six months. And so I they kind of changed the target set. But what the protagonist, in this case to CIA, I was NSA, and I spent a lot of time at the CIA as well as Pentagon and other um remote places. Uh, but the experience of that protagonist very much mirrored my experience of moral conflict and confusion and really questioning everyone's got boundaries and lines in different places, and we all have to make those judgment calls for ourselves of what we're comfortable doing. And so my my protagonist struggles with that.
SPEAKER_01I assume you're not breaking any laws by answering the question.
SPEAKER_02I'm not. You know, I think that at the time I was at the NSA, I had the good fortune of uh General Hayden, who led the NSA, and then he moved over to the CIA. Uh, such a remarkable leader. And when I was there, we'd always the joke was no such agency, right? You couldn't even talk about where you worked. And in the in the period when I was there, he opened that up and allowed people to be a little more transparent, obviously not about what they do day to day, but some transparency about where they worked and um depending on what you were doing, obviously. You know, there's certain rules around uh certain things. But even I was I was even surprised at, you know, you have to have your resume approved anytime you adjust it and what they were comfortable with me saying in terms of part being part of a team that tracked bin Laden, right? So that level of transparency, uh I really have to thank General Hayden for changing that, um, which up to that point really had been far more mysterious to anyone outside the agency. And I do think, to be totally fair, you know, it was part of the need to make sure we get funding and make sure, you know, that um the NSA was as visible in some ways as CIA and some of the other partners. Um, because quite often the CIA is um the one agency people think of when they think intelligence. And the great irony is they're just one of many.
SPEAKER_01When you say General Hayden, are you you're referring to Air Force General Pat Hayden?
SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, my Michael. Michael
SPEAKER_01Hayden. Michael Hayden, I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Yeah. So he um right, he was an Air Force, um, became head of NSA, became head of CIA, um, now has the Hayden Center, uh, remarkable human being. I actually worked with his daughter. Um so got to kind of understand him on a on a different level. I never really spent one-on-one time with him. I was not at that level at the agency. However, he was widely respected.
SPEAKER_01Now when I
SPEAKER_02still is.
SPEAKER_01When I was a kid, my dad took me to the theater to see the James Bond film on Her Majesty's Secret Service.
SPEAKER_02And
SPEAKER_01I've been a fan ever since. Bond first tried using his personality and charm to get what he wanted. And if that didn't work, measures would escalate from there. Is there a standard operating procedure for that, or do you have to have James Bond charm to pull off that tactic?
SPEAKER_02I think that's one of the biggest misconceptions around intelligence is this idea that, well, one, that human intelligence, so humans, you know, the the James Bond, the case officer, the person out in the field is the source of gathering intelligence. The reality is, is that is one small sliver of the entire intelligence picture, right? There's all sorts of ways we get intelligence. And what just to focus on human intelligence for a moment here, the I think the the that perception that the most charismatic person in the room might be the spy is actually the opposite. You want the person who you would never remember, who would not stand out in a crowd, who is completely indistinguishable, and blends in entirely. So that is not James Bond, right? And and so this is where you know Hollywood does an interesting disservice. The reality is it's nothing like what you see in the movies, uh, which is why they're movies, not real life.
[Ad] Info On The Go
SPEAKER_01Now you had mentioned that you were part of the team that tracked Osama bin Laden.
SPEAKER_02Correct.
SPEAKER_01Did that quest begin before
(Cont.)
SPEAKER_01or after the terrorist attacks of September 11th, 2001?
SPEAKER_02So I joined the agency in August 2000, so well before. And there were, you know, there was small teams that were um keeping track of this network. And so he had really risen to high radar with the bombings in the African uh in Africa, the embassy, embassy bombings. And so this idea that it really, you know, post-9-11, yes, everything changed in terms of attention and focus, but there was definitely focus on these emerging threats. But you know, there's nothing like the homeland, you know, to change the picture entirely. For better or for worse, bombings in Africa don't get the same attention that they do, you know, in other places.
SPEAKER_01If we were tracking Osama bin Laden prior to the uh 9-11 terror attacks, did we miss something that we could have or should have caught to prevent them?
SPEAKER_02So this is where I would defer to the 9-11 Commission. And you know, there's plenty of documentation out there around what were what were the failures, right? Um one of the ones that the commission report highlights that I think is very accurate is is really around interagency coordination. And for me, it actually led to leaving the agency and coming back as a private contractor to the FBI as part of a team at Bozalin to stand up an analytic arm around counterterrorism. So this idea that you needed agencies better communicating was something that I think is, you know, has changed a lot since then. Now I've been out of intelligence for quite some time, so I can't I can't uh speak to where it is now. But this idea, did we miss something? I think that the better question is what could we have done better? And I think there is a lot of information out there for people to gather. Unfortunately, I can't talk specifics. That's that is part of the bridge too far.
SPEAKER_01Were you still part of the team when he was ultimately found and eliminated?
SPEAKER_02No, I was not. I had completely um diverted away from intelligence and into at that time, I was doing other federal agencies, so I was consulting, so I was a private contractor. And um I can tell you the feeling I had was relief for the families because this idea of you know justice, and everybody's version of what that justice would be is different. But I if it could provide any feeling of closure or some justice for those families, then then I felt like um that was a huge victory. Now, the other side of that is no single individual is um, you know, they could call it cutting off the head of the snake. Well, the reality with al-Qaeda is you have a pretty diverse um population of groups that are all kind of anti-West, and it did, it doesn't end, terrorism doesn't end with one person. Although you could argue inspirational leaders over time, um, certainly it causes heavy disruption to a network. But the reality is that just taking out bin Laden wasn't the final answer to how we tackle terrorism and how we end terrorism.
SPEAKER_01When tracking Osama bin Laden, did you always have the data you wanted in order to find the answers you were looking for?
SPEAKER_02Well, Bob, these specific questions unfortunately are not things I can talk about.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02Um, but I can tell you that I was enormously impressed um with at least with my teams and the people I was dealing with in terms of their ability to support each other. Now, this the broader communication and those types of interagency things, separate separate thing entirely. But my personal experience was that I was working with some exceptional, exceptionally talented and um uh really uh a specialized group that I really felt were doing their absolute best.
SPEAKER_01Okay, just one more question about Osama bin Laden then. On 9-11, I expected fighter jets to be in the air within minutes after that incident occurred, and there weren't. And it seemed like it took a little while for us to create a response to it. Did we know right away that it was Osama bin Laden? And if so, did we know where he was at that time?
SPEAKER_02No. Well, Bob, these are all great investigative reporting type questions. However, I can't speak to specifics. I can tell you that certainly there were a lot of parties mobilized immediately. Whether it was visible to the American public, that's another matter entirely. Um, but speaking to specifics around bin Laden at that time or response plans, I cannot speak specifics.
SPEAKER_01Got it. Okay. Well let's let's move on then. I have another
SPEAKER_02great.
SPEAKER_01Did you ever wear a hijab to fit in somewhere?
SPEAKER_02No, I did not.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_02Um, no. And um, one of the things about NSA's work is it's not out in the public. It's not as visible, right? When someone you're talking about different types of communications, you know, human intelligence as we traditionally think about uh what spies do, is just again one piece of that puzzle.
SPEAKER_01Now, the premise of your book, Saffron Spy, indicates that your subject may have had some struggles with moral tugs of war. What struggles could there be if you take an oath to defend the Constitution and your job is to hunt down the guy who masterminded the most devastating attack on the United States since the Spanish-American War or whatever fictitious group uh you portray in your book?
SPEAKER_02Right. It gets back to um, and this actually dates back to a Harvard course I took on moral reasoning. When we think about the different moral justifications we make for decisions, and there isn't necessarily a right or a wrong, which is why it makes it a little blurry. When you talk about, yes, defending the constitution, set that aside for a minute. When you think about do the ends justify the means, and you position that against um arguments like content arguments of human basic human dignity, right? These aren't there aren't clear pathways or ways to look at those very different moral frameworks. And so when you think about, like let's take the the hunt for bin Laden as an example, yes, the argument is the ends justify the means. If if the goal is to take down bin Laden, there are many who would argue whatever it takes to achieve that is is morally justified. Now there are other people who would say we operate on a basic human dignity being a moral foundation. And that needs to be part of the equation when decisions are made. And I'm not arguing necessarily that one is right or wrong, but I think when we we try to make things black and white, it makes us it makes it easier for us to digest. But the reality is that these are especially in a case of terrorism and in a case of kind of mass casualty and mobilization of forces, these are tough things to argue and work through and still maintain your moral foundation. And what happens in in my book is this CIA analyst who becomes an operative begins to question her own morality and her own judgment calls, not only at work, but with her in her personal life, which gets very complicated, certainly with her her um boss and this these the networks she deals with, um, and her struggle to find kind of her truth, yet the the commitment she has to her oath, her oath versus her personal moral code. And so when you get to these kind of conflicts, internal conflicts, while you've got major mass casualty events, it it creates, you know, when I think back to my own experience, you really struggle to keep your compass when there is so much at stake and so much going on. So I wanted my protagonist to take the readers through that experience, not to say something was right or wrong, but to show that, especially in the world of espionage, it is incredibly murky.
SPEAKER_01Should a moral compass of someone who has one be ignored if you know that your enemy does not have one or has completely different morals?
SPEAKER_02Well, so what's interesting in that in my book that I that I basically focus on with that argument, this idea that often it's kind of the counter kind of counter-narrative. Often they're using the same justifications that we are. It's just the mirrored version of it. So it is it's quite it's it's a bit of a mind-bender when you think about it. That, you know, I would argue that that let's take the example of bin Laden, he was certainly using in a utilitarian framework of, hey, ends justify the means, in in his mind. And I'm not saying that's right or wrong. I'm just saying the great irony is that any justification can be mirrored by the other side. And that certainly uh complicates the equation, doesn't it? When you think about them having the same kind of moral code,
SPEAKER_01well, I would suspect that they don't have the same kind of moral code, and therefore maybe I could justify abandoning mine in this situation.
SPEAKER_02And what you're getting at, Bob, is I think the the crux of the book, and it's why I wrote it, because I want people to think about that for themselves, not to have some kind of a judgment of the reader, but to force the reader into that space of, well, wait a minute, how am I thinking about this, how I would handle this? Here's here's how I justify it, right? Here's here's my own moral construct. And and so it's it's meant to stir those questions and not have clean answers because that was the hardest part is living with the discomfort of it not being clear. And so it's an odd objective for a book, but I want there to be some discomfort. I want people to walk away from reading the book and really think about where their lines are, not to judge someone else, but to do that introspection.
SPEAKER_01Have have you come to Grips with your own morals since then, or do you still struggle with them now?
SPEAKER_02Well, and it depends on the context. If you're referring to do am I comfortable with what I did in intelligence, the the in my particular case, when I left, I was given a plaque that there was a quote, do the ends justify the means? That was the quote, that was the thing I'd always ask when we were trying to justify an action. And so I think at that time I was very much of that mindset that as long as we achieve our objectives. Now, with some some growth and some reflection, I I have come to realize that it's far more complicated. And do I sit comfortably with it? No, but I think I'm okay with that because I don't think these things are meant to be comfortable. I think these things are meant to cause friction and are meant to cause reflection.
SPEAKER_01You had mentioned that uh James Bond is a fictionalized uh idea of what spying is. Does the romanticized image of a spy mislead those who pursue the profession?
SPEAKER_02Some. I think we all come at it differently. You know, for me, I grew up in a very patriotic household. My father was Force Recon in the Marine Corps in Vietnam. Um, and so I had kind of come from a world of service. And so my lens was very much I I wanted to do something to support my country. And I think others might come at it from a different angle. And I don't think it's necessarily, I'm not trying to say I had some loftier, you know, justification or reasoning for for going in. It's just I didn't grow up watching spy movies or you know, I wasn't I wasn't necessarily intrigued by it from a glamour or you know the sexiness of of the work. I was much more focused on service.
SPEAKER_01You've been clear about some of these uh moral questions that that came up uh throughout or or after your career. What are some of the struggles you go through that you could not have anticipated or that your training didn't prepare you to deal with?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think that no one could anticipate the gravity of 9-11. I mean, that that the scale of that, they say it was, you know, um a lack of imagination on our part to imagine something of that scale. And so I don't know that I could have, I don't know that the agency could have prepared me for that, or I could have psychologically prepared for something of that magnitude, especially at age, you know, 20. I was 23 at the time. I I yeah, I I don't I really don't think anything could have prepared me for that.
SPEAKER_01Well, that certainly, you know, that is uh uh an out an outlier as far as probably the day-to-day operations of whatever it was you you were doing at the time. But did you feel like if you're if you had if you if you're experiencing these moral dilemmas later, uh what could there have been a way that you could have avoided them with uh perhaps a different preparation or training?
SPEAKER_02Hmm. That's a good question, and it's not something I've spent much time thinking through, and I don't want to give you a flippant answer because um I I think uh the best preparation is to know thyself. And I'm not sure that a college-age kid is is fully knows themselves yet. So I think um I I would argue there's something to be said for having some years of experience in other spaces uh that would maybe better prepare and and some kind of time under your belt in the adult world, experiencing things, because I think we are we are products of our experiences. And I think coming out of university and going right into it, I still had very much an academic mindset about things, and I still do today, but life experience, there's there's a huge value in that that um I think is helpful preparation for for things like this.
SPEAKER_01Well, certainly experience is the best teacher, there's no doubt about that.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01Um was there anything that you wished you had experienced that you hadn't?
SPEAKER_02Before going in? Hmm. I think no, because I think some of the things that I never thought would happen, I I got to experience. And that was the kind of bizarre side to what I was doing was that I had exposure to things that maybe if I had been target a different target set or you know a different part of the world, I wouldn't have had those experiences. And so it's hard to it's hard to see the positive, so to speak, uh, of the entire situation. But I do know that the exposure I had was pretty unusual to go that rapidly into something that intense.
SPEAKER_01Kids just fresh out of college uh certainly don't find themselves probably shoulder what you felt like was a great responsibility at that time.
SPEAKER_02I did, yes. I mean, I think uh the level of of being overwhelmed on, you know, certainly I think everybody was on 9-11, but the the weight of that after, everyone felt this weight of um responsibility. And that was a lot to burden on top, a lot of a bur burden on top of what was already difficult work, right?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I I can only imagine uh how President Bush felt uh when he found out about it. Of course, you know, the buck stops there.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01Um, but certainly everyone working for the federal government at that time in these intelligence gathering agencies uh must have uh felt some profound shock and and sorrow.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and I would add on that guilt, uh, which is one of those difficult emotions to sit with, justified or not, I I felt a tremendous guilt. And and I think every anniversary, all those, it's it's kind of a PTSD for a lot, I think a lot of people, the intelligence are not, but that those feelings come back, uh, regardless of yes, we eventually got bin Laden and other things. And you know, it's it's it's still it still brings back all of those memories.
SPEAKER_01Is it getting easier to deal with them as the years go by?
SPEAKER_02Well, what's interesting, and and I think my family thought writing this book would be therapeutic for me, of of revisiting some of those experiences. Uh I believe it or not, actually, it was the opposite. Um, to go back into that space at the depth I did uh for this book took me, took me back to some some dark spots in my in my life. Um, because you know, you think about we've been so focused on in this conversation talking about you know what was happening on the job, but my entire personal life unraveled. And it's not by coincidence, right? So when you're dealing with this level of stress uh on your job, and other, I'm sure there's some plenty of other professions, I think uh, you know, healthcare in particular, right? If you think about COVID, that level of stress and pressure, for that not to have a cascading effect on your personal life, it's practically impossible. So revisiting those experiences in writing this book was difficult. And frankly, I am glad to be on the other side of it of the writing, because to do to write well about these things, you really have to go back to those moments and and live in them, dream them, and and sit with all that.
SPEAKER_01Are you still a spy? It's okay.
SPEAKER_02I am the I am the furthest thing from a spy, which is it's it's funny, the people that know me, so my my life changed dramatically when I moved from the East Coast from DC to Southern California. Um, and it was almost like a shedding of my um whole identity uh when I moved to California, where um I decided I wanted to live on the beach, uh, learn how to surf, and you know, work for the highest bidder. And so I I live I live a very different existence than I did in my time in DC. I loved my time in DC. However, it was time for an entirely new start. And interestingly, writing became a part of my journey only in the early 2020, it was about 2022, um, I started writing my first book. And this is my third book, Saffron Spy. However, it was the reason I wanted to write books was the third book, but I knew I needed some cycles. I needed to really get better at the craft. And so I wrote two books, uh, both I interestingly in this sports nonfiction space, which was an odd place to start, except that all of my books deal with the conflict, the internal conflict and the person versus the institution. And so that's the thread from sports nonfiction over to spy, is this internal conflict that goes on with my protagonists?
SPEAKER_01Well, Lizzie, we only have a few minutes left, and I have one more question for you. Is it possible to completely get out of the spy business? Or is there a part of you that's still in it somewhere or somehow?
SPEAKER_02No, it yeah, I completely left. And a quick story on this: I was actually dating an Iranian nuclear scientist, so he he became a US citizen. However, he was here on political asylum. And that was obviously a problem for the intelligence community. So after, you know, he's he was not a spy, I think, of the Nvidia situation that folks are dealing with and reading in the news right now. That was that was not my circumstance, and and the that was quickly understood by the intelligence community. However, the personal decisions I was making and the life I I wanted for myself was far different. And so leaving the intelligence community really meant revoking my clearances. And once you revoke your clearances, it's like basically giving up all your credentials. And that was a personal decision, but it does take you out of the game entirely.
SPEAKER_01Well, Lizzie, I've really enjoyed our conversation. I hope you have as well. And I want to thank you for spending some time with me in the listening tube today.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Thank you, Bob. And if folks are interested, they can check out my work at LizzieWright.com. That's L-I-Z-Z-Y-W-R-I-G-H-T.com. I've got a lot about these this book, this upcoming, and my other books. Um I love to connect with readers. So if you're interested, please reach out.
SPEAKER_00The listening tube will return at the speed of sound. Send email to thelistening tube at outlook.com.
SPEAKER_01I had only asked Lizzie Wright from where she was speaking to me, and she shared with me, before I even asked another question, what I think adds relevant context to the conversation you just heard. I'll share it with you now.
SPEAKER_02I moved down here from Malibu after the fires. Uh so the Palisades fires that hit coastal California really were the impetus to uh relocate. Uh, you think of climate change and climate refugees, you don't always think Southern California, but
SPEAKER_01in
SPEAKER_02fact, we've got some of the most volatile weather around and climate around. And uh yeah, so I I had uh definitely the firsthand experience of three evacuations within a month and a half. And the third one was enough. We were in hotels for a month.
SPEAKER_01Wow,
SPEAKER_02yeah.
SPEAKER_01Okay, well, I I'm I hope you've been able to settle in and you're more I mean you're more comfortable now.
SPEAKER_02Oh, well, you know, the don't cry for me, Argentina kind of thing, because you know, Southern California, it's all quite magnificent. So I yeah, it we we we left a great spot for another great spot. So learn the learned definitely that there's some value in renting in California.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02The ability to relocate is is a superpower in this day and age. This may be an abrupt segue, but when I wrote this book, well, to be honest with you, I wrote I wrote the majority of the book while we were still living in Malibu, but this book, Saffron Spy, was in me dating back to the early 2000s. And I didn't I didn't know that I wanted to write a book, but I I knew some of the things that I was experiencing in intelligence were worthy of of putting pen to paper. And so to just for for the benefit of the listeners, I started my career in intelligence. And in the world of espionage, you you don't necessarily know what you're signing up for in terms of what you will cover. And this was all pre-9-11. Um, I was part of a team that tracked bin Laden, and it was a crazy time in my life. It escalated rapidly with the coal bombing, and I was part of the assessment team there. And then obviously in 9-11, my world turned upside down along with many of us. Um, and from there, my life became a blur. And it's only with the time and space to think back to those experiences that I felt the need to write a version. Uh you could call this auto fiction, heavy on the fiction part, of what it's like psychologically to live in the world of intelligence with the moral complexity of that. And it's very relevant today as we think of Iran and what's going on and you know, justifications for war.
SPEAKER_01I want to get to all that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But Lizzie Wright's Saffron Spy will be available soon. Lizzie's nonfiction books, including the one about Todd Morinovich, which I'm sure is an eye-opener, are available right now at LizzieWright.com. Thank you to Lizzie for spending some time with you and me in the ListeningTube. Follow the listening tube at thelisteningtube.com, where you'll also find NotThe Headlines and This Week in History. While you're there, click on the green follow button or donate to the program by clicking on the Buy Me a Coffee link on the homepage. Thank you for putting your ear to the listening to I'm your host, Bob Woodley, for that I'll add infinitum.